Direct Debit Increased While in Credit – What to Know

October 8th, 2025
Direct Debit Increased While in Credit – What to Know

Why did my energy supplier raise my direct debit?

Many UK homes feel upset when direct debit payments go up even though they are in credit. A lot of people think if they have much credit in their energy account, the monthly bill should go down, not up. But suppliers do not only look at the credit balance. The companies also think about your energy use, the time of year, and what the cost of energy will be next. They use those things to work out what you need to pay, not just the amount already showing in your energy account.

Knowing why your payment amount changes, even if you use less energy, will help you stay in control of your money. It is good to understand this so you can better manage regular living costs at home.

How energy suppliers calculate direct debits

Suppliers set up your direct debit payments to spread your expected yearly energy usage cost over 12 months. This can help you avoid higher winter payments when you use more heating. With direct debit, the total amount for your energy usage is split, so you do not get big amounts to pay at one time. It is a good way for people to manage their debit every month, no matter if the usage goes up in the winter.

Key factors that influence your payment amount

  • Estimated usage: Your payment history and meter readings help work out how much energy you use.
  • Unit rates & standing charges: If the price cap goes up, direct debit customers will see their payments go up automatically.
  • Seasonality: You use much energy during cold months. To help with this, suppliers add a little extra debited ahead of winter as a buffer.
  • Credit balance: If you have a credit balance, your supplier may still keep some money as a cushion for the future.
  • Tariff type: On a standard variable tariff, your payments will go up and down. With a fixed direct debit, you pay a set amount each month, so costs stay stable.

Why is my direct debit increased while in credit?

If your supplier puts up your payment amount even when you have money left, this can happen for several reasons:

Rising cost of energy

Future price increases affect your forecast. A £200 credit that you get now may not go far if wholesale costs go up before October. During October, new price caps usually start.

Higher winter payments

Credit balances get used up fast when it is the heating season. Many suppliers raise your direct debit in the autumn. They do this to get ready for higher winter payments.

Using more energy than expected

If you use more energy than was expected, you might still have much credit in your account during the summer. But by winter, you could not have enough.

Back-billing or estimate errors

Late meter readings or fixing past readings can make it look like your balance is better than it should be. If you send in your meter readings often or put in a smart meter, your direct debit will stay at the right level.

Your Next Bill Could Be Lower

Use our calculator to see what you’d save — takes under 6 minutes.

Ofgem rules and consumer rights

The regulator, Ofgem, has done checks on how companies set up direct debit payments. They found that some companies did not use accurate energy use data for this.

Under the rules:

  • Suppliers have to use the best information they can get. They should set payment amounts at the right level.
  • Customers must get a notice each time the payment amount changes.
  • Direct debit customers can ask for a refund if they get much credit.
  • There is help for you. The advice consumer service has a trained adviser who you can reach by phone or online chat.

If a supplier does not solve your complaint, you can take it up with the Energy Ombudsman.

Fixed direct debit vs variable direct debit

Energy suppliers usually give you two options to pay through direct debit:

Payment type How it works Pros Cons
Fixed direct debit You pay a set amount each month, based on estimated annual use Predictable bills, easier budgeting Risk of overpaying and holding too much credit
Variable direct debit Payments match the actual bill for that month Reflects real usage, avoids over-crediting Can cause very high bills in winter

Most homes use fixed direct debit plans. This helps spread out the cost over time. But, suppliers often keep customer credit for too long on these debit arrangements.

Can I get a refund if I’m in credit?

Yes. If your energy account shows you have too much credit, you can ask for a refund. The supplier has to give your money back unless they can show that you need it for your next usage. Most refunds go right into your bank account in about 10 working days.

Can I get a refund if I’m in credit

Regional differences across the UK

Ofgem looks after energy markets in Scotland, England, and Wales. There are some things that are different when it comes to schemes and support in these places.

  • Households in Scotland have to go through longer winters. They also use more energy for heating in that time. So, higher winter payments are there for them.
  • In England and Wales, the Great British Insulation Scheme be made to help people get lower bills. It tries to make demand for heating go down.
  • In the UK, there be extra support for vulnerable households. People can get help from programmes, like payment breaks or changing to cheaper tariffs.

Avoiding overpayment on your direct debit

To keep your direct debit payments at the right level, you can use these tips:

  • Send in your meter readings often, or use a smart meter. This helps keep your energy account right.
  • Check your energy account every three months so it is up to date.
  • Ask your provider to tell you how he worked out your payment amount and if it is correct for you.
  • If you find much credit in your account, you can ask for a refund.
  • If you need your payments to match how much you use, think about switching to a variable direct debit. This way, your debit lines up better with your energy usage.

Your Next Bill Could Be Lower

Use our calculator to see what you’d save — takes under 6 minutes.

Common scenarios explained

Scenario Why it happens What you can do
In credit but winter coming Forecasts expect high demand Check if your set amount is too high
Price cap increase Higher unit rates from Ofgem Compare tariffs, consider switching
Using less energy than forecast Direct debit stays high Request adjustment and lower bills
Holding much credit Supplier policy to keep buffer Ask for refund to your bank account

FAQs about direct debits and energy bills

Why did my direct debit increase while I was in credit?

Suppliers do not only check your current balance. They also guess how much energy you will use in the year. If the cost of energy is high or winter is coming, they may raise your direct debit payments. This can happen even if you have much credit on your energy account. They do this to stop you from paying too little and to keep bills steadier over the year.

If you feel the increase is not fair, you can question it. You may ask to see how they worked out the new payment amount. You also can ask for a review of your direct debit payments.

What is the difference between fixed and variable direct debit?

A fixed direct debit means you pay the same set amount each month. This is worked out using an estimate of your yearly usage. A fixed direct debit can help you with budgeting. It also keeps your regular living costs steady. But if you use less energy than they think you will, this can leave you with much credit at the end.

A variable direct debit is different. The payment amount changes every month. It depends on how much gas or electricity you used in that time. A variable direct debit can help you avoid overpaying if you use less energy. But if you use more energy in the winter, it means you could face higher winter payments. This can make it hard for some people to plan their money.

Both direct debit types have their pros and cons. You can talk with your supplier about which is better for you.

Can I lower my direct debit if it’s too high?

Yes. If your direct debit payments seem too high or do not match your real energy use, you can give your supplier up-to-date meter readings or smart meter data. You can ask for them to work out the payments again. Suppliers must keep your payments at the right level by Ofgem rules. If you have built up much credit, you can ask to get some back as a refund to your bank account or you can ask them to lower your monthly payments. If your supplier does not agree without a good reason, you can take your complaint to the advice consumer service or the Energy Ombudsman.

How do I get extra support if I’m struggling?

Suppliers have to give extra support to direct debit customers who need it. This support can be things like giving you more time to pay your direct debit, stopping the payments for a short time, or helping you use hardship funds. If you want more help, you can talk to the advice consumer service. A trained adviser can speak with you on the phone or through online chat to walk you through your choices. Also, if you live in England, Scotland, or Wales, you might be able to get regional energy grants or join efficiency schemes. These can help cut down the amount of energy you use to heat your home. This means your payment amount gets lower, and you can get lower bills in the long run.

How does the price cap affect my direct debit?

If you’re on a standard variable tariff, the payment amount for your direct debit goes up or down with Ofgem’s price cap. Ofgem looks at the price cap four times a year—in January, April, July, and October. The price cap sets the highest unit rates that suppliers can ask for. When the cap goes up, your direct debit payments will usually go up too, even if you have credit. If the cap goes down, your payments should go down. Sometimes, though, suppliers take time to lower them. If you follow news about the price cap, you can know what changes to expect and ask your supplier to adjust your debit amount when needed.

How quickly will refunds reach my account?

If you have a lot of credit in your energy account, you can ask for a refund. The rules set by Ofgem say that suppliers need to process refunds quickly, often in up to 10 working days. The money goes right into your bank account. Some suppliers give refunds on their own at the end of the year. Others ask you to request it.

If your supplier will not give you a refund and does not have a good reason, ask them to give you a written answer. If you need to go further, you can push the issue.

Keep your meter readings up to date. You can also use an app or online chat to track your account. This makes it easier to keep an eye on your credit and ask for refunds.

Do regional factors matter?

Yes. In Scotland, the winters last longer and it gets colder. Because of this, people there usually use more energy to keep homes warm. This need for more heating leads to higher winter payments. In England and Wales, the government has plans like the Great British Insulation Scheme. These help people use less energy for heating, which can lead to lower bills. Local councils and devolved governments also offer extra support. So, you should check the support that is available in your area.

Why do suppliers hold onto customer credit?

Suppliers say it is good to keep a buffer for direct debit payments. This helps your payments stay even the whole year. A household might get much credit in summer when they use less energy. Later, this extra money helps pay for higher winter payments.

Critics think that having a buffer uses up customers’ money when it should not. But Ofgem rules say that suppliers must keep balances fair and pay back extra money if a customer asks. If you feel your supplier holds too much, you can ask for your balance to be sent back. Also, you may ask for your payment amount to change to the right level.

What is the Direct Debit Guarantee and how can it protect me in these situations?

The Direct Debit Guarantee is there to help all UK direct debit customers, including those who pay energy bills this way. With this guarantee, you can feel safe. If your payment amount goes up without warning or for a bad reason, you have rights. This safeguard makes sure people who pay by direct debit in the UK are protected at all times.

  • You must get advance notice, usually about 10 working days, before any change with your direct debit payments.
  • If there is an error, like a supplier taking too much money, making the debit too soon, or not giving you proper notice, you will get an instant refund from your bank account because of the Guarantee.
  • You can stop a direct debit whenever you want. This gives you control if your supplier doesn’t keep your payments at the right level.

This protection helps you feel safe about your money. You won’t lose cash for something that isn’t right. If your direct debit goes up while you are still in credit and you feel it should not, you can ask your bank for help with the direct debit guarantee and not wait for the supplier to sort it out. The direct debit guarantee gives every household comfort. It is like a safety net if anything goes wrong with debit.

Also Read Related Articles

Compare Energy Prices in Just 6 Minutes

Switch today and start saving — quick, easy, and with zero obligation.

4000+ reviews