Car Insurance Prices in the UK: A Regional Analysis for 2024

Are you tired of paying more for car insurance just because of your postcode? You're not alone. In 2024, where you live is still one of the biggest factors determining your premiums. But why is that? And what can you do about it? Let's dive into the latest data on car insurance prices across the UK and explore the reasons behind the regional differences.

The North-South Divide: Car Insurance Premiums by Region in 2024

The Association of British Insurers (ABI) has released the average car insurance premiums by region for 2024, and the differences are eye-opening:

Source: Free Price Compare and prices correct as of 25/03/2024

Drivers in Greater London are paying a staggering £900 more per year on average than those in Northern Ireland. And it's not just London feeling the pinch. The North West and West Midlands are also among the most expensive regions for car insurance.

Average car insurance cost – BY MONTH

Source: Free Price Compare Car Insurance Price Index (January 2023 – January 2024)

Get Quotes

The cost of car insurance has seen a steady climb over the past year, with premiums across the UK reaching unprecedented heights. According to our latest data, the average UK motorist is now facing a car insurance bill of £894.72 as of January 2024, a significant increase from the previous year.

So, just how much can you expect to pay for car insurance? Free Price Compare has compiled a comprehensive car insurance price index, detailing the average cost of premiums across the UK for various age groups between January 2023 and January 2024. Take a look at the table below to see how your age group fares:

What's Driving the Regional Price Gaps?

Insurance companies use a range of factors to calculate your premiums, many of which are linked to your location:

1. Population density: Areas with more people and cars, like London or Manchester, have a higher risk of accidents and claims.
2. Crime rates: Vehicle crime, such as theft and vandalism, is more prevalent in certain parts of the country. If your area is a hotspot, your insurance is likely to cost more.
3. Road conditions: The state of the roads in your region can impact your likelihood of having an accident. Areas with more potholes, traffic jams, and accident blackspots tend to have higher premiums.
4. Driver demographics: Younger drivers typically pay more for insurance than older, more experienced ones. So if you live in an area with a high proportion of young drivers, like a university town, you might see higher overall prices.

The Most Expensive Regions for Car Insurance

London consistently ranks as the most expensive region for car insurance in the UK. The capital's high population density, congested roads, and elevated crime rates contribute to the increased risk of accidents and vehicle-related crimes, driving up insurance costs. In 2024, the average annual premium in London is £1,200, 20% higher than the next most expensive region, the North West.

Other regions with notably high insurance premiums include:

Get Quotes

The Least Expensive Regions for Car Insurance

In contrast, Northern Ireland and Scotland boast the lowest average car insurance premiums in the UK. These regions benefit from lower population densities, reduced traffic congestion, and generally lower crime rates compared to other parts of the country. In 2024, the average annual premium in Northern Ireland is £500, while in Scotland, it stands at £550.

Other regions with comparatively affordable insurance premiums include:

Historical Trends in Regional Premium Differences

Comparing the 2024 regional premium data to previous years reveals that the disparity between the most and least expensive regions has widened over time:

The difference between the highest and lowest average premiums has increased from £550 in 2020 to £700 in 2024, highlighting the growing regional disparity in car insurance costs.

Regional Accident Statistics and Their Impact on Premiums

Accident statistics play a significant role in determining regional car insurance premiums. Regions with higher accident rates are likely to have higher insurance costs, as insurers compensate for the increased risk of claims.

According to the Department for Transport, the following regions had the highest number of reported road accidents per 100,000 inhabitants in 2024:

In contrast, regions with lower accident rates often benefit from more affordable insurance premiums:

Get Quotes

The Relationship Between Car Crime Rates and Regional Premiums

Vehicle crime rates also contribute to regional variations in car insurance premiums. Regions with higher incidences of theft, vandalism, and other vehicle-related crimes typically face higher insurance costs.

The Home Office's 2024 crime statistics reveal the following regions had the highest rates of vehicle theft per 10,000 registered vehicles:

Conversely, regions with lower vehicle crime rates tend to enjoy more affordable insurance premiums:

The Most and Least Expensive Cities for Car Insurance

Let's take a closer look at which cities are the most and least expensive for car insurance in 2024.

Get Quotes

Tips for Cutting Your Car Insurance Costs, No Matter Where You Live

While you can't easily change where you live, you can still take steps to reduce your car insurance premiums:

1. Shop around: Don't auto-renew with your current insurer. Use comparison sites and get quotes from multiple companies to find the best deal.
2. Choose your car wisely: Some cars are much cheaper to insure than others. Factors like safety features, repair costs, and performance all play a role. Research before buying.
3. Increase your voluntary excess: This is the amount you agree to pay out of pocket if you make a claim. A higher excess usually means a lower premium, but ensure you can afford it if you need to claim.
4. Build up your no claims bonus: For every year you drive without making a claim, you'll earn a discount on your premium. The longer you go without claiming, the bigger the discount.
5. Consider a black box policy: Telematics or "black box" insurance uses a device in your car to track your driving habits. If you're a safe driver, you could save money with this type of policy.

The Future of Car Insurance Pricing: Could Location Become Less Important?

As technology evolves, some experts predict that location could become less of a factor in car insurance pricing in the future.

For example, the rise of telematics means that insurers can base premiums more on individual driving behaviour rather than broad location-based risk factors.

Similarly, as more cars become connected and self-driving, the risk of accidents is expected to decrease. This could lead to lower premiums across the board, regardless of location.

However, location will likely continue to play a role in car insurance pricing for the foreseeable future. Factors like population density, crime rates, and road conditions are not going to disappear overnight.

Car Insurance Claims in the UK: How Location Matters

It's not just your premium that's affected by where you live. The likelihood and cost of making a car insurance claim also vary significantly by location.

According to the ABI, the average car insurance claim pay out in the UK in 2024 was £3,200. However, this figure varies widely by region:

As you can see, the average claim pay out in Greater London is more than double that of Northern Ireland.

This is due to a combination of factors, including:

• Higher repair costs in London and other major cities
• More advanced and expensive vehicles in urban areas
• Higher incidence of vehicle crime in cities

So, not only do drivers in certain areas pay more for their insurance, they're also more likely to make a costly claim.

Get Quotes

Frequently Asked Questions

Why do car insurance premiums vary so much by location in the UK? 

Car insurance premiums vary by location because insurers use location-based data to assess the risk of insuring drivers in different areas. Factors like population density, crime rates, road conditions, and driver demographics can all impact the likelihood and cost of claims in a given region.

Is it fair for drivers in some areas to pay more for car insurance than others? 

The fairness of location-based pricing in car insurance is a matter of debate. While the cost differences can be frustrating for drivers in high-premium areas, insurers argue that they are simply reflecting the higher risks and costs associated with insuring vehicles in those locations.

What can I do to lower my car insurance premiums if I live in an expensive area? 

While you can't change your location (easily), you can still take steps to potentially lower your car insurance costs. These include shopping around for the best deals, choosing a car that is cheaper to insure, increasing your voluntary excess, building up your no claims bonus, and considering telematics or black box insurance.

Will location always be a factor in car insurance pricing? 

While some experts predict that location could become less important in car insurance pricing as technology evolves, it's likely to remain a significant factor for the foreseeable future. Factors like population density, crime rates, and road conditions are not going to disappear overnight.

How can I find the cheapest car insurance in my area? 

The best way to find the cheapest car insurance in your area is to shop around and compare quotes from multiple insurers. Use price comparison websites and consider using an insurance broker who can help you find the best deals for your specific circumstances.

The Bottom Line

Where you live is one of the biggest factors affecting your car insurance premiums in the UK, but it's not the only one. By understanding the reasons behind location-based pricing and taking steps to reduce your risk profile, you can potentially save money on your car insurance no matter where you call home. But remember, the cheapest policy isn't always the best. Make sure you have the right level of cover for your needs, and don't be afraid to pay a little extra for quality service and reliability. After all, you never know when you might need to make a claim.

References

• [1] www.abi.org.uk