Comprehensive vs Third Party Car Insurance UK

Choosing between comprehensive car insurance and third party car insurance is an important step for UK drivers. It does not matter if your car is new, old, or affordable. The kind of car insurance policy you choose will change how much you pay each year. It also changes your peace of mind and the help you get if your car has a problem. A good insurance policy can make things better for you in many ways when trouble comes.

There are a lot of levels of cover for car insurance out there. Some of the common ones are third party, third party fire and theft, and full or comprehensive. A lot of people feel unsure about which one to pick. Many drivers say this, is it better to go with comprehensive car insurance, or should I have just the basic legal minimum?

This article talks about different types of car insurance UK drivers can choose. It looks at how much you have to pay for car insurance, especially for cheap cars and older cars. The article also talks about what you get with comprehensive insurance. You will read about the benefits of comprehensive insurance. It also shows the pros and cons of third party cover.

What are the main car insurance cover types in the UK?

There are three main types of insurance policies you can get in the UK.

1. Third Party Only (TPO)

• This is the lowest level you can get by law.
• It pays money if you hurt someone or break things that are not yours.
• It does not help fix your own car if there is a car accident.
• Pros: It is often the cheapest choice for people. Some say risky people get this one.
• Cons: It gives no help for your own car. You may end up spending more as time goes by.

2. Third Party Fire & Theft (TPFT)

• The plan gives you all that the TPO plan has.
• It also adds fire damage cover and theft cover for your own car.
• You will not get any cover for your own car if you make the accident happen.
• A lot of people pick this if they have cars that do not cost much.

3. Comprehensive Insurance

• This is the highest level of cover you can have.
• It will protect you, your own car, and other people, even when you are the one who caused the accident.
• You will also get cover for fire damage, theft cover, and often some optional extras. These extras may be things like windscreen cover, a courtesy car, or personal accident cover.
• Sometimes, comprehensive cover costs less than TPFT. This is because the insurer thinks people who pick the highest level of cover take fewer risks.

Comparing comprehensive vs third party cover

Many people think that third party policies will always cost less. But this is not right all the time. Insurance companies sometimes charge more for third party cover. This can happen because younger and high-risk drivers are the ones who often pick it. At the same time, safer and older drivers pick comprehensive policies. Insurers think these people are less risky, so they feel better when backing them.

Most of the time, there is not a big difference in price between TPFT and comprehensive cover. The cost can be less than £50 or £100. Many people feel that paying a bit more for comprehensive insurance is a good idea.

Compare Car Insurance

Save up to £515* on your car insurance

Compare Quotes Retrieve Quote

Is comprehensive car insurance worth it?

The answer to this question depends on the value of your car. It also depends on your budget. You should think about how much risk you want to take as well.

When comprehensive insurance is worth it

• Your car’s value is £3,000–£10,000: If your car needs big repairs, it can cost a lot of money. This is why it be important to the have some protection.
• You’re a young driver: When you are a young driver, you might have a higher chance of having an accident. A good, complete plan helps give you peace of mind.
• You live in a high-crime area: You want theft cover. It will also help protect your car from vandalism.
• You want peace of mind: If you want peace of mind, it’s worth paying a little more to know the car is covered for all the things that can go wrong.

When third party may be enough

• Your car is worth less than £1,000: If your car does not cost a lot, there is no good reason to pay £600 for full cover.
• You have savings to replace your car: Some people have extra money to buy a new car if something happens. They feel okay to take that risk.
• You rarely drive: If you do not drive much and keep the car safe, third party fire & theft may work well for you.

Benefits of comprehensive insurance

Comprehensive policies are made to take care of the car, but they also give you a lot more. You can get many extras with them.

• You get cover for your car if there is a car accident, even when you are the person at fault.
• Theft cover and defense from fire damage are also in the plan.
• Personal accident cover is there to help if you or the people in your car get hurt.
• Optional extras could be breakdown cover, legal cover, or use of a courtesy car.
• A lot of car insurance providers now have better ways to claim, and people feel more happy with these companies.

Even when you look at cheap cars, you see the benefits come with more value than just third party cover. For these, you get more than basic protection. You also have some extra safety that can be good for us all. So, if you want to feel safe in your car, this can be a good choice.

Comprehensive insurance for old or cheap cars

A lot of people want to know if it’s a good idea to get comprehensive insurance for cars that are old or not very valuable. You should think about the insurance costs and the value of your car to help you decide.

• If you get the car that costs £1,200, buying the comprehensive cover for £600 might not be good for you.
• If your car is worth £4,000, most of the time it is good to get the comprehensive cover for £700.
• If you own the £9,000 car, you should know the comprehensive cover is almost always the best thing to have.

Example:

• A Vauxhall Astra from a past year, priced at £1,500, may have comprehensive insurance at £420. In that case, you get TPFT insurance for £350, so that might be the better choice.
• A Ford Focus with a value of £6,000 could have comprehensive insurance for £620 or TPFT for £580. This time, it may be good to pick comprehensive insurance because it is a better deal.

How to compare car insurance cover levels

When you look at car insurance cover levels, you need to do more than just check the price. It is good to know what you get for the cost. There may be things in the, car insurance, plan that are worth looking at. So, make sure to read what the, plan, covers before you choose.

1. Read the policy wording: It is important to read the policy wording. Some plans that say they are “basic” or comprehensive may not include things like windscreen cover in what they offer.
2. Check optional extras: You should look for optional extras in your cover. Check if you get something like breakdown cover. You may need to pay around £30–£80 more for breakdown cover with some plans.
3. Look for personal accident cover: Many plans do not have personal accident cover to start with. If this is something you want, be sure to look for it in the plan you pick.
4. Review excess levels: Think about the level you choose for excess. If you raise your voluntary excess from £250 to £500, the premium you pay can get lower, sometimes by over £100.
5. Check for FCA regulation: Every company who likes to sell insurance in the UK should be allowed to by the Financial Conduct Authority. Make sure the insurer you pick follows the Financial Conduct Authority rules.

The lowest price for comprehensive cover may not always be the right choice for you. What you get in the plan matters more than just how much you pay. Real value comes from what is included, not only the cost.

Special considerations for young drivers

For a young driver, you need to think well before you pick comprehensive or third party insurance. It is good to know what each option gives you. This can help you get what fits your needs.

• Named driver: You can add your parent or a person who knows how to drive well. This can bring the cost down a lot.
• Black box policies: A black box uses telematics to check how you drive. You may pay less for comprehensive cover than for third party.
• Car choice: Picking the right car is the best way to save. Cars like the Toyota Aygo or Skoda Citigo are in groups 1–5 and can help you get comprehensive cover cheaper.

Example:

• A 19-year-old who wants to get insurance for a £2,500 Ford Ka may have to pay around £1,800 for TPFT.
• If they use a black box in the car and put a parent down as a named driver, the price for comprehensive insurance could be £1,400.

For young drivers, the best idea can be to choose comprehensive insurance. It gives you a way to build a no-claims bonus faster. Over time, this can help you pay less on your insurance costs.

Comprehensive insurance and electric cars

As electric cars go down in value, many now be sold for under £10,000. For these cars, it is important to have electric car insurance. A good car insurance plan for these EVs often gives you:

• The battery cover can be worth a lot. It may cost several thousand pounds.
• The cover comes with the charging gear and the cables.
• Some normal features are fire damage cover, theft cover, and accident protection.

Even if you buy an EV that is not high in price, the cost to fix it or change parts can go up quickly. A comprehensive plan can be the safer way. This plan covers you for more things that might come up. It can give you peace of mind.

Compare Car Insurance

Save up to £515* on your car insurance

Compare Quotes Retrieve Quote

Temporary car insurance: short-term options

Drivers who only need car insurance for a short time can get temporary car insurance. This type of car insurance works well if you need it for just a few days or weeks.

• The insurance protects you and the car, so both you and the car be safe.
• It can last for one day or up to three months.
• If you take or use a car and have this insurance, the owner gets to keep their no-claims bonus.

If you borrow a car that has a value of £7,000 for two weeks, you can expect to pay about £100 to £150 for temporary comprehensive cover. The cost for this is often much lower than adding yourself to an annual policy.

FAQs about comprehensive vs third party car insurance