Car Insurance Loyalty Penalty UK – Why It Costs You

What is the car insurance loyalty penalty?

The car insurance loyalty penalty is when people who have stayed with the same company for a long time pay more to renew than new customers do for the same cover. Before the FCA changed the rules in 2022, many companies gave lower prices to new customers. They slowly put up the price for old customers who did not leave.

Millions of motor insurance customers paid too much, as they did not look for better deals. The Association of British Insurers says customers who stayed loyal paid £200 to £300 more each year. This is compared to new buyers who got the same motor insurance policy.

Compare car insurance quotes now

Why do renewal prices increase each year?

Renewal prices can go up or down because of a wide range of factors. These are not always about loyalty. The company checks your risk every year and makes changes for a range of factors.

• The kind of car you have, what model it is, and how much it is worth.
• How old the driver is, how much driving experience they have, and their postcode.
• The total miles driven, any past claims, and history of incidents.
• Cost of claims you have made and repair records.
• Higher prices in the market and changes to overall car insurance premiums.

These things help set the price for car insurance. Companies use your history, your car’s value, and other factors to work out how much you pay for your car insurance premiums. A higher cost of claims or more past incidents can push your price up.

Before the FCA got involved, people used this way to raise prices for no good reason. Loyal customers ended up paying more in renewal premiums. This was called “price walking.”

Now, when you get renewal quotes, they must be the same as the base price given to new customers. But, prices may still go up. This can happen if there are more accidents in your area. Labour costs may also be higher or the data in the Motor Insurance Database may change.

Compare Car Insurance

Save up to £518* on your car insurance

Compare Quotes Retrieve Quote

What did the FCA change about loyalty pricing?

From January 2022, the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) said that insurers must charge the same price to people who renew their home or car insurance as those who buy it new. This means your car insurance and home cover will now cost you the same as new customers for the same type by law.

The change stopped loyalty penalties. But, insurers can still set prices with the range of factors they use when figuring out risk.

Insurers will have to show the premium from last year next to the new price when they send out renewal letters. The Association of British Insurers backed these changes. They believe it can help people trust insurers again and bring more open pricing.

This change stopped unfair loyalty pricing. But, it did not end changes in the market. The cost of claims, and higher prices for parts, plus labour costs, still make a difference in motor insurance prices.

Has brand stacking replaced the loyalty penalty in the car insurance industry?

Since the FCA reforms, many analysts say that brand stacking has slowly become the new pricing way for the industry. It has now taken over what used to be loyalty penalties.

Brand stacking is when one insurance company has more than one sub-brand. Each brand is marketed to people who use comparison websites. The different brands are made for different people and price points. This can make it feel like there is a big range of providers. But many of these brands may be owned by the same main company.

Why insurers use brand stacking

Brand stacking helps insurers stay seen in many price ranges. This way, they can reach different kinds of buyers, follow FCA rules, and still keep their earnings.

• It lets insurers show up several times on comparison websites with different names.
• Drivers who change may not know they are going from one brand to another that the same company owns.
• It helps insurers keep their profit margins by deciding how they set premiums for each of their brands.

Market visibility and segmentation

Insurers use brand stacking to show up several times in search results. A parent company can put more than one brand on aggregator sites. Some brands target people who want budget cover. Other brands focus on offering comprehensive policies with more features.

This helps insurers show up first in search results for both people who are low-risk and high-risk. It also lets them try out new pricing ideas while following FCA rules about fair prices.

Customer perception and switching illusion

Many people think that changing insurance companies will always save them money. But a lot of the time, the same underwriter is still behind their new policy. The Association of British Insurers has asked that insurers make it clearer who owns each brand.

Brand stacking is not against the law, but it does not give clear information to motor insurance customers. A lot of people with motor insurance think they are changing to a new insurer, but they may not be. This makes real competition less, and it gets harder for people to know which companies truly give better value.

Impact on competition

When insurers spread customers across brands, they can keep making money without looking like they are raising costs. One sub-brand will show good deals to get new people in. The other brand may go after loyal or higher-risk drivers. It can charge them slightly higher prices.

To the customer, this may look like good, healthy competition. But a lot of what might seem like very different quotes can often come from the same insurer group.

How drivers can avoid confusion

• Look at the underwriter name found in your policy papers.
• Go through the policy wording and see if text shows up more than once for different brands. This could mean the brands are be owned by the same company.
• Don’t only focus on price. Also check how good the service is, how fast they handle claims, and read reviews.
• Call an insurance broker if your case is not simple or if you have a changed vehicle.

If you know who really gives you your car insurance, you can make sure there is real competition. This will help you not pay extra for what is really the same thing, just from the car insurance provider you already use.

Find cheaper car insurance today

Should I auto-renew my car insurance policy?

Auto-renewal can make things easy, but it does not always give the best value. Insurers now must send a road notification before your renewal. The notice will show what the price was last year and what it will be this year.

If you see your renewal premium go up, it’s a good idea to look at other insurance products. To stop auto-renewal, just tell your insurer or broker before the renewal date. Get your next motor policy ready so there will not be any gap between your old and new cover.

Continuous cover is needed by UK law. This means you must always have motor insurance. The Motor Insurance Database keeps track of this. The police use Automatic Number Plate Recognition to check if you have the right motor insurance.

When is the best time to switch car insurance companies?

The best time to look for new quotes is 21 to 26 days before your current renewal. This is when you can get the lowest prices from a range of providers. This is because companies think people who shop early are less risky.

If you wait until the last few days, you can get higher quotes. This is because people who renew late are seen as more of a risk. Always check your no-claims discount certificate with your previous insurer. This helps make sure it moves to your new policy the right way.

Compare Car Insurance

Save up to £518* on your car insurance

Compare Quotes Retrieve Quote

What affects car insurance prices besides loyalty?

Even though the FCA banned the loyalty penalty, the price you pay for your car insurance can still go up or down. This is because a wide range of factors, not just how long you have had your policy, are used to work out your premium. Each insurance company has its own way to rate the risk, looking at many details to guess how likely you are to have a claim. They update these numbers all the time, so the price may change, even if nothing about you has changed.

Insurance companies use the Motor Insurance Database, the Association of British Insurers, and past claim records. They do this to check risk and change how they set prices. The way these things impact what you pay for your motor insurance is about more than just how or when you renew your cover.

Vehicle type and specifications

The type of car you drive can change the base price of your insurance. Cars that have big engines, more electronics, or need expensive repairs will cost more to insure. The insurance group system made by the ABI and Thatcham Research puts cars into groups from 1 to 50. A car in group 1 is the cheapest to insure. A car in group 50 is the most expensive.

A small 1.0-litre hatchback is usually in group 5. A fast coupe can be in a group above 40. The coupe ranks higher because it goes faster, can be stolen more easily, and has expensive parts. Even things like alloy wheels, spoilers, or tinted windows can put your car in a higher group. These add-ons make your car look worth more. This makes the cost of claims go up as well.

Insurance companies will look at if your car has any changes from how it came from the factory. You have to tell them about every change, no matter how small. This includes things like a sports exhaust or new suspension. If you do not say something about your car’s changes, your insurance may not cover you.

But, putting in extra safety or security parts on your car—like immobilisers, alarms, or tracking devices—can help. These things can make the car less likely to be stolen, and they may make what you pay for insurance a little less.

Driver profile and behaviour

Your personal profile also has a big effect on the price. Things like your annual mileage, how long you have been driving, and your job all put you in a certain risk group. If you drive a lot, especially during rush hour, you are more likely to have an accident. This is why insurance companies often charge you more for the premium.

Younger drivers and people who just got their license usually see higher prices. This is because they do not have a history of driving safe. If drivers build a claim bonus by going several years without making any claims, they can lower their costs a lot over time.

More insurers now offer black box insurance. It is also known as telematics policies. These help new or careful drivers show they are low-risk. A special device or app on the phone tracks speed, how you brake, and when you drive. The data lets insurers give discounts to careful drivers. For some people, it can lower their costs by up to 25% after one year.

What you do for work can change the risk. Teachers and civil servants, plus engineers, can have lower rates for their car insurance. A professional driver or person who delivers things may have to pay more. They spend more time driving. Each insurance provider looks at job data in a different way. So, you should check with more than one car insurance company before you pick one.

Location and environment

Where you live and where you keep your car at night can change how much you pay for your car insurance. Insurance companies look at different areas called postcode zones. They check things like how often people make claims in that area, local crime, and how many accidents happen there. If the car stays on a private driveway or in a locked garage, it is seen as safer. Cars left on public streets are not as safe, so insurance for them may cost more.

Urban places where more people live close together and there is a lot of traffic often have more small accidents and thefts. This can make the average price of car insurance higher. For example, if you driving in the middle of Birmingham, you might have to pay a lot more than someone who lives out in the countryside of Cumbria for the same car.

The cost of claims in your area can change how insurance companies set prices. If it costs more for garages, labor, or replacement parts where you live, then you may see a higher renewal premium. The Motor Insurance Database helps check that all registered cars stay insured. This keeps pricing correct and makes sure they follow the UK’s legal requirement for continuous motor insurance cover.

Policy type and features

The type of car insurance you get will set how much you pay at first. A third-party only policy is the lowest cover you can have under UK law. It does not look after your own car if it gets damaged. A third-party, fire and theft policy will also pay if your car is stolen or caught on fire, on top of the legal cover. Most people in the UK choose comprehensive insurance. This type will pay for damage to your car and to other cars. Even though it gives the most cover, comprehensive insurance can be less money. Insurers feel that drivers with full cover act more safe and do not take big risks.

The base price of your insurance will go up a bit if you add optional extras. These extras include breakdown cover, a courtesy car, or legal expenses protection. But, these features can give you peace of mind if there is an accident or a claim.

Some insurers give multi-car discounts or bundle deals with home insurance. If you pay each year instead of every month, you may pay less because you avoid instalment interest. You can also try to lower what you pay by raising your voluntary excess. Make sure the amount stays doable for you if you need to make a claim.

Additional influencing factors

Some small details can make your insurance price go up or down. The time of year you buy your insurance matters. Many people get better deals if they renew between 21 to 26 days before their insurance runs out. Companies look at the number of cars like yours that are out there. They check how long repairs usually take. They also watch market trends. All these things help them set the price.

Each insurer looks at these things in their own way, so the same driver details can get very different quotes. It all depends on the range of providers being looked at. This is why two people, with the same car, parked on the same street, can get prices that are hundreds of pounds apart from different insurers.

Car insurance premiums keep changing. They do not just look at who you are and what car you drive. The rates also shift because of new risks, claims, and how people act when they buy car insurance. The best way to get a price that matches your life right now is to compare car insurance policies each year. This helps make sure you pay for what fits your needs and not old ideas that do not update.

Sales channels and insurer model

Policies you buy with an insurance broker might be a bit higher in price because of commission. Still, you get advice that fits you. You also can find specialist insurers with them. If you choose direct online policies, the cost will often be lower. These are less flexible than using a broker.

Many big insurers that sell on comparison websites often use brand stacking. This lets them offer several prices in the market. By doing this, they can look good in different parts of the market and stay competitive.

Each insurer looks at these things in its own way. They use special rules for it. Even if two people have the same car, they may get very different price quotes from the same car insurance provider. The best way to get a good price is to compare plans often, keep your information up to date, and know what changes your new quote for car insurance.

FAQs about the car insurance loyalty penalty